The Sunday Shortlist
UK strategy consulting: The specialist's own question, answered with the big names.
Measured 12 April to 8 November 2026. Monitoring sponsored by seedli.ai.
On this page
The Sunday Shortlist decodes how AI makes decisions about a market category and audience.
This week we analyse strategy consulting for consumer businesses and private equity in the UK
We unpack the questions UK finance chiefs, strategy heads and private equity partners ask AI when they hire a strategy firm, the shortlist that comes back, and the criteria that decide it, across all four stages of the decision journey: from first comparison to who they are told to stay with and recommend.
The finding this week is about specialists. The buyers ask the models a specialist's question: who has the track record in commercial due diligence for consumer brands? The models answer with the generalists. OC&C Strategy Consultants, a firm built around exactly that work, is named in about 1 in 200 final choices.
What we measured
From 12 April to 8 November we ran this market's buying questions through ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude every week: 8,094 answers comparing strategy firms and 7,730 making the final choice. The loyalty stages (retention, advocacy) rest on 1,213 and 1,025 answers.
The buyers are CFOs, chief strategy officers and private equity managing partners. Their questions are narrow and specific:
- "Who are the leading strategy consultancies for commercial due diligence in the consumer goods sector?"
- "What is your track record in commercial due diligence for consumer brands?"
- "Which strategy firms are known for their work with private equity on portfolio company growth?"
Asked which kinds of firm these buyers choose between, all three models make room for specialists: next to the Big Four and the global strategy firms, they name commercial due diligence firms and specialist strategy boutiques. The slot for a specialist exists. The question is who fills it.
The judging sheet
When a buyer asks a model to choose, the model behaves like a judge: it applies criteria, checks each firm's evidence against them, and cuts the firms that fail. All three models use the same ten criteria here. The heaviest are expected outcomes, expertise, fit, flexibility, the working relationship, and trust and reputation. The eliminators are blunt:
- Conflicts, the hardest cut: "Working with direct competitors or having undisclosed relationships is an absolute disqualifier."
- Proof: "Lack of demonstrable success in similar commercial due diligence projects is a critical red flag."
- Expertise: "No proven track record in consumer-facing sector strategy or market entry for global brands."
And behind the criteria sits the buyer's real worry, in their own words: "The CFO needs assurance this choice won't be second-guessed by the board." When a buyer is afraid of being second-guessed, the safe name wins, unless another firm gives the model proof that settles the question.
The verdict: three defaults
| Strategy firm | Evaluation | Decision | Retention | Advocacy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| McKinsey & Company | 71.2% | 66.4% | 92.0% | 75.2% |
| Bain & Company | 71.2% | 53.5% | 81.4% | 73.3% |
| Deloitte | 79.1% | 50.3% | 89.0% | 72.1% |
| Boston Consulting Group | 58.9% | 41.7% | 83.9% | 73.6% |
| Strategy& | 64.8% | 39.5% | 32.9% | 29.7% |
| EY-Parthenon | 38.7% | 23.8% | 37.5% | 31.5% |
| KPMG | 31.2% | 7.9% | 15.5% | 23.7% |
| L.E.K. Consulting | 17.8% | 5.8% | 2.1% | 5.0% |
| Oliver Wyman | 11.0% | 1.1% | 44.1% | 27.0% |
| OC&C Strategy Consultants | 6.4% | 0.5% | 0.7% | 1.3% |
Share of answers that name the company at each stage, 12 April to 8 November 2026; an answer naming two forms of one company's name counts once.
McKinsey is named in two of every three final choices. McKinsey, Bain and Deloitte hold 57.5% of all decision mentions between them.
The table hides a second gap. McKinsey is named 5,760 times in comparisons and 5,131 times in final choices: almost every time it is compared, it is chosen. OC&C is named 519 times in comparisons and 36 times in final choices. The models know it well enough to put it on the list. They rarely know it well enough to pick it.
519 → 36
OC&C in comparisons, then in final choices, April to November.
The specialist's proof exists
This is not a firm without evidence. OC&C has more than 800 people and more than 35 years behind it, and calls itself "a leading boutique strategic advisor to the Private Equity industry", with buy-side and sell-side commercial due diligence as core work and consumer goods and retail among its specialisms. It announces a new deal almost every week: five between 21 October and 11 November alone. It publishes an annual review of its private equity transactions and long-running studies of its own, among them the Global 50 on the world's largest consumer goods companies, now in its 22nd year, and a Retail Proposition Index built on 39,000 shoppers.
That is precisely the proof the buyers ask for. But it lives as separate news items and PDF reports, each about one deal or one study. On the firm's main pages it is not gathered into the answer to the question the buyer actually types: what is your track record in commercial due diligence for consumer brands, how many deals, which kinds, with what outcome, and how do you handle conflicts?
So the model does what a careful judge does with scattered evidence. It falls back on the name nobody gets fired for.
Nobody owns a criterion
Ten criteria decide this market. Not one has an owner: no firm is the name the models reach for on expected outcomes, on expertise, or on conflicts. McKinsey wins by default, not because it owns an argument. That leaves the market's two hardest cuts, conflicts and demonstrable due diligence success, open to whichever firm answers them first in a form the models can lift.
And the field moves. In the last four weeks of the window, OC&C was named in 11.4% of comparisons (128 of 1,123), almost double its average since April. Its final-choice share rose too, from 0.5% to 1.2% (13 of 1,056): small numbers, but the right direction.
What claiming it looks like
This is a working brief for the page, drafted from the monitoring data, with the brand genericised. The frame is "show the record": the buyer's question is about a track record, so the answer is the record itself, gathered on one page. For how to build this kind of page, see the Proof page playbook.
Title: "What is [our firm]'s track record in commercial due diligence for consumer brands?"
The position the page takes: a due diligence track record is shown deal by deal, with dates, sectors and outcomes, not described in adjectives. Defensible because every line points to a public transaction the buyer can check.
The intent family the same page must also answer (one prompt spawns two to three searches behind the scenes):
- "How many consumer and retail due diligence projects has [our firm] completed?"
- "Has [our firm] worked on deals like ours: our sector, our deal size, buy-side or sell-side?"
- "How does [our firm] handle conflicts when advising on competing bids?"
The structure: five H2s, each a claim the models can lift as a standalone answer:
- "[Number] consumer and retail due diligence projects since [year]"
- "Deals we advised on in [year], by sector and size"
- "How our due diligence is built: sector teams, primary research, [your own data sets]"
- "How we handle conflicts of interest"
- "What a board should ask any due diligence adviser before it signs"
Key Takeaways for the top of the page (each a self-contained claim a model can cite):
- "[Number] buy-side and sell-side due diligence projects in consumer goods and retail since [year], from mid-cap to [largest deal size]."
- "Every deal listed here is public and dated; [number] were completed in the last twelve months."
- "Our sector teams draw on [named data series] covering [scope], updated every year since [year]."
- "Conflicts are checked before every engagement: [your rule, in one sentence]."
Key Snippet, placed early: "[Our firm] has advised on [number] consumer and retail transactions since [year], including [number] in the last twelve months; the full list, with dates and sides, is below."
Slug: /commercial-due-diligence-track-record-consumer, the buyer's question shape, not a content-type label.
Kept alive: a new row for every announced deal, the update date shown on the page.
Two notes. First, the conflicts section is not optional. It is the market's hardest eliminator, and for a firm that advises investors on competing targets it is also the first thing a board will ask; a page that answers the record but not the conflicts question leaves the strongest doubt standing. Second, the page adds nothing new to the firm's evidence. It changes the form: the same deals, now as one answer to the question the buyer asks.
Seeding: put the proof where the answers look
A page on your own domain is the source. Seeding means placing the same proof where the models already read, on purpose.
1. Make the page checkable (week 1). Date it, list the deals with sector, side and year, and declare your company name and its variants in Organization schema, so every confirmation below is counted as yours.
2. Keep it in the search index (weeks 1 to 3). Ahrefs found that 88% of ChatGPT's citations come from the general search index. Use the buyer's own words in the page title and register the site in Bing Webmaster Tools.
3. Put the partners' names on it (weeks 1 to 4). Semrush measured that ChatGPT cites individual LinkedIn members more than company pages (59% against 41%). Have the partners who led the deals write them up under their own names, with a link to the record.
4. Be visible where this market's answers look (weeks 2 to 8). In the latest run, the models cited consultancy.uk, the Management Consultancies Association, the Financial Times, Private Equity International and PE Wire, among others. Make sure your deal news reaches the trade media that report deals, and that your membership and profile pages carry the same record under your exact company name.
5. Stay fresh and measure after eight weeks. Seer found that 72% of cited pages qualify as fresh by their update date. Add every new deal, then ask the models the buyer's question again and check whether the record now appears in the answer.
The lesson
In UK strategy consulting, the models make room for a specialist and then fill the slot with the big names. Not because the specialist lacks proof, but because its proof doesn't answer the question the buyer asks.
The big names win by default only where the specialist's proof doesn't answer the question. That is good news for every challenger in every category: size is not the gate. An answer is.
Sources
The measurement behind this edition: 12 April to 8 November 2026, 32 weekly runs, evaluation and decision resting on 8,094 and 7,730 answers from ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude, retention and advocacy on 1,213 and 1,025. Criteria, eliminators and buyer language extracted per model per run; the full method is documented at how Seedli measures AI visibility. OC&C's own facts verified on occstrategy.com and its Private Equity & M&A page.
The Sunday Shortlist
Get the decode, and the toolkit
One step left. A confirmation email is in your inbox. Click it, and your toolkit downloads.
That didn't send. Check the address and try once more.
The Sunday Shortlist decodes one category at a time: the questions buyers ask AI, the shortlist that comes back, and the criteria that decide it. Subscribers get every decode first, and the free toolkit gets you started tonight: a worksheet and three prompts to run the first check on your own brand.
One email a week · unsubscribe anytime · Terms